Home   About us   About ADR   NADR Services   Publications
  Forms   Members   Forums   Links   NMA
• Adjudication
• Adjudication Federal Australia
• Adjudication Law Reports
• Adjudication Law Reports 1999
• Adjudication Law Reports 2000
• Adjudication Law Reports 2001
• Adjudication Law Reports 2002
• Adjudication Law Reports 2003
• Adjudication Law Reports 2004
• Adjudication Law Reports 2005
• Adjudication Law Reports 2006
• Adjudication Law Reports 2007
• Adjudication Law Reports 2008
• Adjudication Law Reports Index
• Adjudication New South Wales
• Adjudication New Zealand
• Adjudication Northern Territory
• Adjudication Queensland
• Adjudication Singapore
• Adjudication South Australia
• Adjudication Tasmania
• Adjudication Victoria
• Adjudication Western Australia
• ADR Law Reports
• ADR Law Reports 1997
• ADR Law Reports 1998
• ADR Law Reports 1999
• ADR Law Reports 2000
• ADR Law Reports 2001
• ADR Law Reports 2002
• ADR Law Reports 2003
• ADR Law Reports 2004
• ADR Law Reports 2005
• ADR Law Reports 2006
• ADR Law Reports 2007
• ADR Law Reports 2008
• ADR Law Reports Index
• Alernative Dispute Resolution
• Arbitration
• Arbitration Law Reports 1996
• Arbitration Law Reports 1997
• Arbitration Law Reports 1998
• Arbitration Law Reports 1999
• Arbitration Law Reports 2000
• Arbitration Law Reports 2001
• Arbitration Law Reports 2002
• Arbitration Law Reports 2003
• Arbitration Law Reports 2004
• Arbitration Law Reports 2005
• Arbitration Law Reports 2006
• Arbitration Law Reports 2007
• Arbitration Law Reports 2008
• Arbitration Law Reports Index
• Arbitration Older Reports
• Banking
• Commercial Law Reports 1997
• Commercial Law Reports 1998
• Commercial Law Reports 1999
• Commercial Law Reports 2000
• Commercial Law Reports 2001
• Commercial Law Reports 2002
• Commercial Law Reports 2003
• Commercial Law Reports 2004
• Commercial Law Reports 2005
• Commercial Law Reports 2006
• Commercial Law Reports 2007
• Commercial Law Reports 2008
• Commercial Law Reports Index
• Conflicts of Law
• Constitution Law Reports
• Constitutional Law
• Construction
• Construction Law Reports
• Construction Law Reports 2000
• Construction Law Reports 2001
• Construction Law Reports 2002
• Construction Law Reports 2003
• Construction Law Reports 2004
• Construction Law Reports 2005
• Construction Law Reports 2006
• Construction Law Reports 2007
• Construction Law Reports 2008
• Construction Law Reports Index
• Dispute Review Boards
• Education
• Employment
• Intellectual Property
• Legal Research
• Legal Skills and Practice
• Mediation
• Medical
• Private International Law
• Public International Law
• Public Law
• Shipping & Trade
• Sports Law
• Who's Who



View a printer friendly version of this page.
Alfred Mcalpine Construction Ltd v Panatown Ltd No1 [1998] ABC.L.R. 02/05
Recovery of nominal / substantial damages by a non-owner. 5th February 1998
by Evans LJ; Hutchison LJ; Mantell LJ.

Alfred Mcalpine Construction Ltd v Panatown Ltd No2 [1998] ABC.L.R. 03/13
Recovery of nominal or substantial damages by a non-owner. 13th March 1998
by Evans LJ; Hutchison LJ; Mantell LJ.

Anns v Merton London Borough Council [1977] ABC.L.R. 05/12
Liability of local authorities for defects in dwellings constructed by builders in their area. (subsequently overturned by Murphy v Brentwood [1990]). 12th May 1977.
by Lords Wilberforce; Diplock; Simon ; Salmon; Russell. Crown Copyright

Ballast Wiltshier Plc v Thomas Barnes & Sons [1998] ABC.L.R. 07/29
Retention Monies : Interpretation of contract. 29th July 1998.
by His Honour Judge Bowsher. Crown Copyright

Barclays Bank Plc v Fairclough Building Ltd [1994] ABC.L.R. 05/06
Contributory liability, if any for its own losses suffered where a sub-contractor negligently fails to perform its duties safely (damaging property during cleaning operations causing asbestos pollution), where the mode of operations has been sanctioned by the employer. Held : No liability under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945 : CA. 6th May 1994.
by Nourse LJ; Beldam LJ; Simon Brown LJ. Crown Copyright

Beaufort Developments (NI) Ltd v Gilbert-Ash NI Ltd [1998] ABC.L.R. 05/20
Pre HGCRA : Jurisdiction to open up and amend certificates available to judges. Northern Regional Health Authority v. Derek Crouch Construction Co. Ltd. [1984] Q.B. 644 wrongly decided and overruled. But where stated to be final arbitrators and adjudicators (see power in HGCRA and Scheme) need express power to open and revise. House of Lords. 20th May 1998.
by Lords Goff; Lloyd; Nolan; Hoffmann; Hope : Crown Copyright.

Beoco Ltd. v Alfa Laval Co Ltd. [1993] ABC.L.R. 12/21
Collateral warranty : Sub-contractor - supplier : Heat exchanger failed - repairs carried out by sub-contractor. Employer restarted production before testing carried out. Plant failed. Held : Premary responsibility for failure lay with the employer. Employer nonetheless entitled to recover repair costs and economic costs of production lost up to the time of the explosion but not thereafter. Costs of the main action to follow the event. 21st December 1993.
by Balcombe LJ; Stuart-Smith LJ; Peter Gibson LJ. Crown Copyright

Bernhard\'s Rugby Landscapes Ltd v. Stockley Park Consortium Ltd [1997] ABC.L.R. 02/07
Global Claims : Landscaping contract. 7th February 1997.
by HHJ Humphrey Lloyd : Crown Copyright

Birse Construction Ltd v St David Ltd [1999] ABC.L.R. 02/12
Jurisdiction : Proof of existence of a contract, containing an arbitration agreement that gave rise to jurisdiction and right to a stay to arbitration. 12th February 1999.
by His Honour Judge Humphrey Lloyd. Crown Copyright

Bolton v Mahadeva [1972] ABC.L.R. 04/13
Lump sum contract : Substantial performance : Contractor agreed to install a central heating system. It was so defective that repair costs amounted to a quarter of the value of the contract. CA held overrulling the court of 1st instance that there was no substantial performance and the contract price was not therefore due. 13th April 1972.
by Sachs LJ; Buckley LJ; Cairns LJ. Crown Copyright

British Crane Hire v Ipswich Plant Hire [1973] ABC.L.R. 11/13
Responsibility for loss to plant falls, by virtue of standard plant hire terms and conditions, on the hiror. Heavy crane sank into the mud. Cost of recovery lay with the hiror. 13th November 1973.
by Lord Denning MR; Megaw LJ; Sir Eric Sachs.

Cambridge Water Co Ltd v Eastern Counties Leather plc [1993] ABC.L.R. 12/09
Liability for occupier of land for pollution of the underground water table - torts of nuisance and Rylands v Fletcher. 9th December 1993.
by Lords Templeman : Goff ; Jauncey ; Lowry : Woolf. Crown Copyright

Cape Durasteel Ltd v Rosser & Russell Buildings Services Ltd [1995] Adj.L.R. 08/04
Stay : An agreement to adjudicate is similar to and should be treated in the same way as an agreement to arbitrate. Contractual adjudication agreement - predating HGCRA. QBD : 4th August 1995.
by HHJ Humphrey Lloyd. Crown Copyright

Chandler v Welland (t/a IJ Welland Building Contractor) [1996] ABC.L.R. 12/05
Payment problems arose in respect of a domestic contract when the employers encountered marital problems. The Builder obtained a C.C.J and entered a charge on the property. 4 years later the wife paid the sums due in order to release the charge then attempted to pursue a counterclaim for defects which was dismissed by the judge the settlement ended all claims. CA on unsuccessful appeal from QBD. (Mr. Justice Popplewell). 5th December, 1996
by Hirst LJ; Judge LJ. Crown Copyright

Channel Group v Balfour Beatty Ltd. [1993] ABC.L.R. 01/21
Application for stay of court action to Dispute Review Board proceedings. 21st January 1993.
by Lords Keith; Goff; Jauncey; Browne-Wilkinson; Mustill : Crown Copyright

Cruden Construction Ltd v Commission for the New Towns [1994] ABC.L.R. 12/21
Declaration granted that a dispute had not yet crystallised ?arbitration invalid. Whilst a demand had been made which had not been satisfied, insufficient detail of the complaint had been provided for the other party to be able to make any decision as to whether or not to pay. Referred to as an authority in a number of the construction adjudication cases canvassing the issue of what is a dispute. Official referee. 21st December 1994
by Gilliland QC : Crown Copyright

D & F Estates v Church Commissioners for England [1988] ABC.L.R. 07/14
Liability of main contractor for negligence of sub-contractors - scope of MCs duty of care. 14th July 1988.
by Lords Bridge; Templeman; Ackner; Oliver; Jauncey. Crown Copyright

Darlington Borough Council v Wiltshire Northern Ltd [1994] ABC.L.R. 06/28
Damages post assignment : third party rights : exceptions. 28th June 1994.
by Dillon LJ, Steyn LJ, Waite LJ. Crown Copyright

Davis Contractors v Fareham Urban DC [1956] APP.L.R. 04/19
Case stated : Arbitration : Did the unavailability of labour and material resulting in an overrun of 23 weeks in a construction contract strike at the heart of the contract, displacing it and making the employer liable on a quantum meruit basis for services? Held : No : Result : contract breached by late performance. House of Lords. 19th April 1956
by Viscount Simonds; Lords Morton; Reid ; Radcliffe; Somervell. Crown Copyright

Dredging & Construction Co Ltd v D.T. Simmonds & Delta Civil Eng. Co Ltd. [1999] ABC.L.R. 10/07
Jurisdiction of arbitrator to continue to rule on jurisdisction once he had made an interim ruling on jurisdiction - functus officio. Construction dispute. Main contract cl 66 ICE 6th : Sub-contract cl 18 FCEC form of sub-contract, 1991 Edition. Official Referee. 7th October 1999.
by His Honour Judge David Wilcox. Crown Copyright

Ellis Tylin Ltd v Co-Operative Retail Services Ltd [1999] ABC.L.R. 03/08
Collateral contract ; Service contract : Whether this was supplemented by an oral collateral contract whether there was a right to lawfully terminate main contract : held : no collateral contract : termination was unlawful. TCC. 8th March 1999.
by HHJ Peter Bowsher : Crown Copyright

Foster Wheeler Wood Group Engineering Ltd v. Chevron U.K Ltd [1996] APP.L.R. 02/29
Abatement and Set off : Whether set off / abatement available as a defence to a claim for payment of design and drawing service to a North Sea Oil rig available for work not done and for damages for defective works amounting to breach of contract. Held Notionally Yes this was a work and labour contract not professional services but in the circumstances the contract already provided sufficient remedies so implied term for abatement not needed. QBD.Official Referee. 20th February 1996.
by HHJ Humphrey Lloyd : Crown Copyright

Hall & Tawse South Ltd v Ivory Gate Ltd [1997] ABC.L.R. 11/21
Letters of Intent : Reasonable sums due and quantum meruit distinguished : where a contract is in a very brief form and does not specify sum due, costings to be determined on the evidence. 21st November 1997
by Thornton J.

Henry Boot Construction Ltd v. Alstom Combined Cycles Ltd [1999] ABC.L.R. 01/22
When does an action for payment accrue and time start to run for the purposes of limitation - when work is done or on certification? Held : On certification or when the certificate should have been issued. This applies individually to interim payments and to the final account. 16th June 2005.
by Dyson LJ; Thomas LJ. Crown Copyright

Howard Marine & Dredging Co. Ltd v A. Ogden & Sons (Excavations) Ltd. [1977] ABC.L.R. 12/13
Whether or not there was a collateral contract regarding capacity of vessels for dumping spoil at sea : whether breached : and quantum of damages for breach.13th December 1977
by Denning MR; Bridge LJ; Shaw LJ. Crown Copyright

J Jarvis & Sons Plc v Galliard Homes Ltd [1999] ABC.L.R. 11/12
Letter of intent : Stay to arbitration : whether a contract - whether arbitrator had jurisdiction. AA 1950. Held : No contract no arbitration. CA. 12th November 1999.
by Evans LJ, Schiemann LJ, Lindsay J. Crown Copyright

JFS (UK) Ltd, Tilghman Wheelabrator Ltd v. DWR Cymru Cyf [1998] ABC.L.R. 03/03
Leave to amend : Section 35(3) of the Limitation Act 1980. \"... neither the High Court nor any county court... shall allow a new claim ... other than an original set-off or counterclaim, to be made in the course of any action ... \" Leave granted. TCC. 3rd March 1998
by Thornton Q.C. Crown Copyright

Junior Books Ltd v Veitchi Co Ltd [1982] ABC.L.R. 07/15
Liability of specialist nominated sub-contractor for economic loss to a factory for the negligent laying of the factory floor - where the factory owner relied upon the skill of the floor layers. 15th July 1982
by Lords Fraser; Russell ; Keith; Roskill; Brandon.

Linden Gardens Trust Ltd v Lenesta Sludge Disposals Ltd [1993] ABC.L.R. 07/22
Employer assignment of benefit of construction contract - whether effective and whether original employer can recover on behalf of subsequent owner. Prohibition against assignment of benefit and burden under a construction contract. Joint action with St. Martins Property Corp Ltd v Sir Robert McAlpine & Sons Ltd. 22nd July 1993.
by Lords Keith ; Bridge ; Griffiths; Ackner; Browne-Wilkinson. Crown Copyright

Mellowes Archital Ltd v Bell Projects Ltd [1997] ABC.L.R. 10/15
Abatement and set off under DOM/1. Inter-relationship between set off and abatement : Are they mutually exclusive? CA. 15th October 1997
by Butler-Sloss LJ; Hobhouse LJ; Buxton LJ. Crown Copyright

Midland Land Reclamation Ltd, Leicestershire CC v. Warren Energy Ltd [1997] ABC.L.R. 01/20
Payment claim : validity of assignment - whether or not set off allowed. 20th January 1997.
by Bowsher J. Crown Copyright

Midland Veneers Ltd v Unilock HCP Ltd [1998] ABC.L.R. 03/12
Letters of Intent : Whether or not a contract brokered and if so on what terms. Judge found there was no contract. This was a finding of fact not law and thus not amenable to appeal. 12th March 1998.
by Evans LJ; Peter Gibson LJ; Thorpe LJ; Crown Copyright

Murphy & Sons Ltd v. ABB Daimler-Benz Transportation (Signal) Ltd [1998] ABC.L.R 12.02
Letters of comfort / intent : whether a contract existed : whether party estopped from denying a contract.: TCC. 2nd December 1998
by His Honour Judge Hicks QC. Crown Copyright

Murphy v Brentwood District Council [1990] ABC.L.R. 07/26
Liability of Local Authorities for negligently approving construction works. Overturns Anns v Merton LBC - discusses pure economic loss and policy issues. 26th July 1990.
by Lords Mackay (LC) ; Keith; Bridge; Brandon ; Ackner; Oliver ; Jauncey. Crown Copyright

Northern Regional Health Authority v Derek Crouch Construction Co Ltd [1984] ABC.L.R. 02/17
Arbitration clause gave arbitrator power to open up review & revise architects certificates. Held : power confined to arbitrator on whom conferred : not available to a court. Application to stay arbitration refused since arbitration was the only way to challenge an architect's certificates. NB Beaufort v Gilbert-Ash overturned Crouch : HGCRA gives adjudicators the power to open up and revise certificates. CA. 17th February 1984.
by Donaldson M.R. Dunn LJ, Browne-Wilkinson LJ. Crown Copyright

Percy (G) Trentham Ltd v Archital Luxfer Ltd [1992] ABC.L.R. 07/20
Contract formation : The court had to decide whether or not a construction contract had been concluded. The court concluded that a contract had been concluded, either as confirmed by a series of communications or at the very least on the basis of Brogden v Metropolitan Railway (1877) 2 A.C. 666 implied contract by performance. cf what is a ?written contract? for the purposes of adjudication and arbitration. CA. 20th July 1992.
by Neill LJ, Gibson LJ Steyn LJ : Crown Copyright

Rackline Ltd v National Library Of Wales [1999] ABC.L.R. 04/16
Consolidation of tenders; Rackline made three tenders and asserted that if accepted they would constitute one contract. Court held : Library accepted contract No3 alone. 16th April 1999.
by Roch LJ; Tuckey LJ; Otton LJ. Crown Copyright

Royal Brompton Hospital National Health Trust v. Frederick Alexander Hammon [1999] ABC.L.R. 01/08
Measure of damages. Sums paid in settlement on compromise of disputed claim by a non-party. Whether Biggin v Permanite principle applicable if liability as well as quantum compromised. 8th January 1999.
by HHJ John Hicks QC. Crown Copyright

Ruxley Electronics & Construction Ltd v Forsyth [1995] ABC.L.R. 06/29
Damages for breach of contract : Assessment based on economic loss - not on cost of restatement unless it goes to the heart of the commercial purpose of the contract. 29th June 1995
by Lords Keith; Bridge ; Jauncey ; Mustill; Lloyd : Crown Copyright

Smith v Eric S Bush (A Firm) [1989] ABC.L.R. 04/20
Liability of a mortgage company valuer to the purchasor to exercise a duty of skill and care where purchasor relies on the information. 20th April 1989
by Lords Keith; Brandon ; Templeman; Jauncey. Crown Copyright

Spartan Steel and Alloys Ltd. v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd. [1972] ABC.L.R. 06/22
Liability of a contractor for interrupting electricty supply to a steel works limited to physical loss. Pure economic loss - viz lost production not covered by the tort of negligence. 22nd June 1972.
by Lord Denning M.R. : Edmund-Davies LJ; Lawton LJ, Crown Copyright

VHE Construction Plc v. Alfred McAlpine Construction Ltd [1997] EWHC TCC 370
Whether or not there was a contract and whether payment due on terms of contract or quantum meruit. Existence of a contract : Novation : Letters of Intent : Yes : Blue Form. Terms determined by construction of agreement - not through conflicting evidence. 14th April 1997.
by HHJ Peter Bowsher. Crown Copyright

Wallace v. Brian Gale Associates [1997] ABC.L.R. 03/07
Tomlin Order - settlement of building dispute. Remedial work involved. Claimants then sought a declaration that the plaintiffs costs of and concerned with the implementation of the order are to be borne by the defendant. Order granted. : 7th March 1997.
by HHJ Humphrey Lloyd. Crown Copyright

Our publications are provided in PDF format, in order to view them you will need Adobe's free Acrobat reader. Acrobat reader can be downloaded from Adobe by following the link to your left.

Top of page

    Copyright © NADR 2000, all rights reserved.